SJ Logo
A Journal of Crime, Conflict & World Order
Books Available

The Iron Fist and the Velvet Glove: An Analysis of the U.S. Police

Tony Platt et al. (2nd printing, 1977). 232 pp., paper, ISBN 0-935206-02-07. $12.95

"...highly recommended for it provides a valuable overview of the police and their role in society." -- National Lawyers Guild Newsletter

A highly informative history and now classic analysis of the U.S. police from a critical perspective. Addresses all aspects of the subject, from special weapons teams and political surveillance to pacification programs and women on patrol. Excellent for study groups, community organizations, and classroom use in political science, history, sociology, and criminology. Includes chapters on: The Police and the Crisis of the 1960s, Contemporary Strategies, Military-Corporate Model (Technology, SWAT, Women on Patrol, Team Policing), LEAA, Guidelines for the Future, Police and the Empire, Rent-A-Cop: The Private Police Industry, Controlling the Police: Liberal Reforms Organizing the Police Popular Struggles, Political Surveillance. Also: Annotated Bibliography & Research Guide.

Available in print and Acrobat pdf format.

Written by: Lynn Cooper, Elliott Currie, Jon Frappier, Tony Platt, Betty Ryan, Richard Schauffler, Joy Scruggs, and Larry Trujillo, with Contributions by: Bill Bigelow, Michael Klare, Nancy Stein, and Millie Thayer

"A landmark text in the political analysis of the police." Ian Taylor, University of Sheffield, England; co-author, The New Criminology

"In addition to providing a useful guide to further research, it represents a necessary and provocative alternative to the conventional view of the American police and their function." Critical Sociologist

"A succinct analysis that reveals the real relationships in U.S. society." Mike Brake

"A major contribution to our understanding of the history, development and functions of the U.S. police." Paul Takagi

TABLE OF CONTENTS

I. Introduction

II. Origins and Development of the Police

1. The First Police

2. Growth of Police

III. Professionalizing the Police

3. The Police and the Progressive Movement

4. World War II to the 1960s

5. The Law Enforcement Assistance Administration

6. Police Militancy

IV. The Iron Fist

7. The Military-Corporate Model

8. Technology

9. SWAT

10. Political Surveillance

V. The Velvet Glove

11. The Pacification Model

12. Women on Patrol

13. Team Policing

VI. Expanding for Business

14. Rent-a-Cop: The Private Security Industry

15. Policing the Empire

VII. Conclusion

16. Police in the 1970s

17. Summarizing Experience

18. Implications for Organizing

VIII. Resources

19. Bibliography

20. Research Guide

21. Documents

Punishment and Penal Discipline: Essays on the Prison and the Prisoners' Movement

Edited by Tony Platt and Paul Takagi (2nd printing, 1982). 200 pp., paper, ISBN 0-935206-00-0. $14.95

The present crisis in prison conditions has been decades in the making. What are its real causes? What are the class forces at work in the penal system? This important anthology of 16 essays selected from Crime and Social Justice addresses these and other questions. Sections on: Political Economy and Punishment, Contemporary Penal Discipline, the Prisoners' Movement, and much more, placing the current penal crisis in a historical and theoretical context. Also included are evaluations of two much-discussed works by Michel Foucault and Michael Ignatieff. Contributors include: Herman and Julia Schwendinger, Dario Melossi, Ivan Jankovic, Karen Wald, and others.

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Contributors 

Preface

Perspective and Overview

I POLITICAL ECONOMY AND PUNISHMENT

Introduction

GEORG RUSCHE: Labor Market and Penal Sanction:
Thoughts on the Sociology of Criminal Justice

DARIO MELOSSI: Punishment and Social Structure

GREGORY SHANK: J. Thorsten Sellin's Penology

II THE PENITENTIARY

Introduction

PAUL TAKAGI: The Walnut Street Jail: A Penal Reform to Centralize the Powers of the State

RUSSELL HOGG: Imprisonment and Society Under Early British Capitalism

DARIO MELOSSI: The Penal Question in Capital

MARTIN B. MILLER: At Hard Labor: Rediscovering the 19th Century Prison

III CONTEMPORARY PENAL DISCIPLINE

Introduction

IVAN JANKOVIC: Labor Market and Imprisonment

IVAN JANKOVIC: Social Class and Criminal Sentencing

RICHARD SPEIGLMAN: Prison Psychiatrists and Drugs: A Case Study

STEPHEN J. PFOHL: Deciding on Dangerousness:
Predictions of Violence as Social Control

IV THE STRUGGLE INSIDE

Introduction

JOHN PALLAS AND BOB BARBER: From Riot to Revolution

BOB MARTIN: The Massachusetts Correctional System:
Treatment as an Ideology for Control

KAREN WALD: The San Quentin Six Case: Perspective and Analysis

DEBBY BEGEL: An Interview with Willie Tate

HERMAN SCHWENDINGER AND JULIA SCHWENDINGER: The New Idealism and Penal Living Standards

Luis Talamantez: Poems

Copyright © 1980, Social Justice/Global Options.

Click on the icon to the left to download the "Preface."

Overview of the Book

After an informative "Introduction" that outlines changes in policing and criminal justice institutions during the 1960s and 1970s, the seven remaining sections are divided into four general topics. Sections II and III provide an extensive historical analysis of the origins and role of the police in the U.S., beginning with the crudest forms of policing -- such as slave patrols and the watch system -- and tracing their development into the modern urban department. Although the form of policing has changed considerably over time, depending on changes in the mode of production from an agricultural to industrial economy, the class control functions of the police in capitalist society have always remained paramount. The book focuses especially on the movement to modernize and professionalize the police during the Progressive Era, since it was during this period that the state apparatus was expanded and became more sophisticated. Next is an overview of developments in policing through the 1960s and a more detailed analysis of the Federal Law Enforcement Assistance Administration, which increasingly became the major source of subsidies and planning for the criminal justice system. This part of the book concludes with information about and an analysis of militancy within police departments, its roots and contemporary form, especially focusing on its implications for understanding the internal dynamics of the police apparatus.

The major part of the book, sections IV, V, and VI, analyzes recent strategies and developments within the modern police system. Sections IV and V examine the major ideological and strategic directions that city police forces have been taking since the 1960s, focusing on the development of new technologies and Paramilitary police units, and the rise of the “police-industrial” complex on the one hand, and on the other the emergence of new strategies of community pacification. These sections include a closer look at specific aspects of the iron fist (such as SWAT and political surveillance) and the velvet glove (such as women police and team policing). Section VI examines two aspects of the continuing expansion and diversification of the repressive apparatus -- first, the export of U.S. police training and techniques to repressive regimes, especially in the Third World, in an effort to achieve political stability for multinational corporations, and second, the booming business in private police at home.

Section VII examines developments in the police, especially the impact of the fiscal crisis, summarizes the experience of organizations and popular movements in their struggles against the police (including a critique of the limitations of liberal reformism), and discusses the implications for organizing. The last section of the book contains an extensive bibliography, listing books, journals, and other materials, as well as a research guide to government documents and other sources of information. Section VIII also includes select documents and a list of organizations working against police repression at that time.